Gun Violence in America – When Will Enough Be Enough?

It was meant to be a quiet afternoon.

Three weeks after the heartbreaking mass shooting at Annunciation Catholic School in Minneapolis, Minnesota, a shooting that claimed the lives of innocent schoolchildren and shook our monastic community to its core, I sat down to write a reflective blog post. My intention was to mourn, to call for peace, reflect on the inaction that has followed and to pray for change. But before I could complete even half the page, my phone buzzed with another alert: two more shootings: one at a high school in Evergreen, Colorado, and another at Utah Valley University.

And within moments, the headlines shifted focus.

Not because the lives of high school students in Evergreen were any less important, but because news broke that Far-Right political commentator Charlie Kirk had been shot in the neck at an outdoor event at Utah Valley University. He later died at the hospital.

As if on cue, the national conversation twisted itself into knots. What should have been a moment of collective grief quickly became a call to arms, literally. Almost instantly, voices from the right began to call for more guns, more ammunition, and "retaliation" for the shooting of one of their own.

But we say, as monks, as Christians, as humans:
Violence is never the answer!

The Unending Toll of Bloodshed
We said it after Columbine.
We cried it after Sandy Hook.
We wept after Parkland.
We shouted it after Uvalde.
We mourned after Annunciation Catholic School.
And now we say it again, after Utah Valley and Evergreen High School.

When will enough be enough?
​
How many more children must die in their classrooms?
How many more public figures must be gunned down on live TV or at campaign rallies?
How many more "thoughts and prayers" must be offered before they are paired with action?

We do not rejoice in any death, neither of the famous nor the forgotten. Just as we fervently prayed for the recovery of former President Donald Trump after he was shot in Pennsylvania, so too do we lift our prayers today for Charlie Kirk. For his soul. For his family. For those who mourn him. And yes, we even pray for the shooter. Because that is the way of Christ.

Violence Begets Violence
When voices online call for vengeance instead of justice, for firepower instead of peace, they only perpetuate the cycle of bloodshed. Calls for more guns in response to gun violence are not a solution, they are a symptom of a culture that has grown comfortable with violence as a form of problem-solving.

But what did our Lord say?
"Lord, do You want us to command fire to come down from heaven and consume them, just as Elijah did?" But He turned and rebuked them, and said, 'You do not know what manner of spirit you are of. For the Son of Man did not come to destroy men’s lives but to save them.'"
—Luke 9:54–56

Jesus rebukes the disciples' instinct for violent retaliation. He came to save, not to destroy. And if we claim to be followers of Jesus, we cannot afford to ignore that rebuke.

A Deafening Silence from Our Leaders
Every time a shooting happens, we ask:
"Will this finally be the moment that changes everything?"

But it never is. Our government continues to do next to nothing. Instead, we see the same political theater play out, partisan bickering, shallow condolences, and empty promises.

Yet the American people are not silent. A Fox News poll showed that even their audience largely supports common sense reforms:

• Stronger background checks
• Stricter red flag laws
• Mandatory waiting periods
• Higher age requirements for semi-automatic weapons

The overwhelming majority of Americans support these measures. But somehow, our elected officials, across all parties, fail to act. Why?

The answer is not complicated: money, political cowardice, and a fear of losing power. And in the meantime, children die. Teachers die. Politicians die. Protesters die. Worshippers die.

Caught Between Extremes
We’re caught between two destructive extremes:

• The far right calls for more guns, even arming teachers and clergy.
• The far left sometimes calls for a total ban, dismissing the Second Amendment entirely.

Neither approach is sustainable.

We, as monks, do not carry weapons. We trust in God and in peace. But we understand the complexity of life in the world, and we do not suggest naïve solutions. What we do suggest is the middle ground of reason: enforce existing laws, tighten regulations, close loopholes, and prioritize safety over political gamesmanship.

This isn’t about ideology. This is about human life. Every mass shooting, every school lockdown, every emergency alert, it chips away at the soul of a nation that claims to be “under God.”

Living by Christ’s Standard
As Orthodox Christians, we do not get to cherry-pick which teachings of Christ we follow.

If we denounce the violence of our enemies but justify the violence of our allies, we are hypocrites. If we offer prayers without working for peace, we are complicit. If we call for vengeance while quoting the Prince of Peace, we blaspheme His name.

Let us instead echo the words of St. Paul:
"Do not be overcome by evil, but overcome evil with good."
—Romans 12:21

We will never stop praying.
We will never stop mourning.
We will never stop calling for peace.
But today, we add our voices to the millions who say:
Enough is enough.

A Call to All People of Good Will
To our elected officials: do your job and protect your people.
To our clergy: preach peace, not partisanship.
To our fellow Christians: live as disciples, not as cultural warriors.
To the American people: hold your leaders accountable.

And to those who have lost someone to gun violence, we mourn with you. We walk beside you. And we pray, with tears and hope, that change will come.

Lord, have mercy.
Christ, have mercy.
Lord, have mercy.